Tuesday, November 17, 2026

There is an ad on TV at the moment for Microsoft Copilot which says a long-term employee called Carmen is plagued with demands from colleagues and these are solved when she uses A.I. to answer their questions.

Snag is, once A.I. has been adopted, Carmen will almost certainly lose her job. An admission A.I. makes when asked about Carmen’s future.

This is the script for the ad:

Voiceover: "Carmen's been here 20 years. Carmen knows everything, which is why Carmen has to help with... everything."

Colleague 1: "Carmen, quick question: is that the right logo?"

Colleague 2: "Did I pitch this?"

Colleague 3: "Who owns the Nordic account?"

Colleague 4: "Carmen, where's the file?"

Voiceover: "But today, Carmen has had enough. So she shows them Work IQ and Copilot. Now everyone can find the answers, and Carmen can get back to her actual job."


I asked A.I. about this and it claimed she wouldn’t but then admitted she might. Here’s the answer it produced:

Why Carmen Would Likely Keep Her Job

• AI struggles with context and judgment. Finding a file or checking who owns the Nordic account is simple data retrieval. Knowing why a client is unhappy, navigating office politics, or deciding whether a pitch fits a client's unspoken needs still requires human judgment.

• Institutional memory goes beyond documents. After 20 years, Carmen knows things that were never written down in a file or email—such as past mistakes, unwritten company rules, and key personal relationships.

• Her value increases when freed from "admin." If Carmen spends half her day acting as a human search engine, she cannot do the strategic work she was actually hired for. Offloading repetitive questions lets her lead projects, mentor junior staff, and solve complex problems.

When Carmen's Job Could Be at Risk

• If her role is purely administrative. If Carmen’s primary function is simply gatekeeping information, routing requests, or managing basic logistics, an AI tool that automates those tasks makes her role much harder to justify.

• If management focuses strictly on cost-cutting. Some companies use AI productivity gains to justify reducing headcount rather than expanding what their existing team can achieve. If leadership sees that a smaller team can handle the workload with AI, senior staff with higher salaries can sometimes become targets for restructuring.

• If she resists using the tools herself. In modern offices, employees who refuse to adopt AI tools often fall behind peers who use them to work faster and take on broader responsibilities.

I reckon that means Carmen’s a goner, especially as she’s the oldest employee in the office and will almost certainly be earning the most.

No comments: